Sindel Noble

Providing Legal Help When You Need It Most

Unusual defendant in mortgage fraud case: a judge

There are many criminal offenses that involve some form of fraud. The essence of the offense is typically some form of concealment.

Mortgage fraud is one those forms. It often includes misstatements made in loan applications in order to obtain financing for a real property purchase.

In the St. Louis area and across the country, it is generally handled as a federal offense. There are also state-level charges that are possible in such cases. Rarely, however, is the defendant in such cases a sitting judge.

Yet that is what happened in a recent Michigan case. Last week, a federal judge sentenced Diane Hathaway, a former justice of the Michigan Supreme Court, to a year in prison for mortgage fraud.

Hathaway was found to have concealed assets from her lender when seeking to execute a short sale on her personal residence. The bank agreed to the sale, accepting less than it was owed.

But before the sale, Hathaway had made fraudulent transfers to family members in order to hide her assets from the bank. The hidden assets included a debt-free home in another state.

Hathaway's attorney had requested a sentence of probation and community service. But the judge sentenced her to a federal prison term of a year and a day. The former judge would most likely not be behind bars for that long, however, because federal prison terms are normally completed through a period of supervised release in the community.

The former judge was emotional and remorseful at her sentencing. She described herself as a broken person, deeply ashamed and disgraced.

Source: The Huffington Post, "Diane Hathaway, Ex-Michigan Supreme Court Judge, Sentenced to Prison For Faud," Ed White, May 28, 2013

    • Richard H.Sindel | Best Lawyers In America | Best Lawyers - 2016
    • Richard H. Sindel | America's Most Honored Professionals | 2015
    • Top Attorneys in Missouri & Kansas | 2014 | Richard H. Sindel
    • Top Attorneys in Missouri & Kansas | 2013 | Richard H. Sindel
    • Super Lawyers
    • AV Peer Review Rated. Highest Rating For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability
    • Richard H. Sindel | Best Lawyers | Lawyer of the year | 2011 | Criminal Defense: Non-White-Collar St.Louis
    • MATA - Helping To Balance The Scales Of Justice
    • Member of the Missouri Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
    • Member of the National Association of Criminal Defence Lawyers
    • The Bar Association of Metropolitan St. Louis
    • U.S.News| Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms | 2010
    • Charles M. Shaw Award
    • Bar Register Preeminent Lawyers
    • The Missouri Bar
    • Top Listed in Best Lawyers | The world's premier Guide
Email Us For A Response

How Can We Help?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy