Sindel Noble

Providing Legal Help When You Need It Most

St. Louis man released after wrongful conviction

DNA evidence has had a profound effect on the criminal justice system. In Missouri and across the country, many people have been exonerated after new evidence made available in the last two decades showed their convictions were wrongful.

But even when DNA evidence is inconclusive, a national advocacy group called the Innocence Project is sometimes able to overturn wrongful convictions. In one such case, a St. Louis man was released from prison after serving nearly thirty years on a murder conviction made possible by deeply flawed procedures.

The man had also been convicted of rape, sodomy and burglary in connection with the same crime, in which a 31-year-old woman was killed.

The circuit court judge who released the 56-year-old man voided all of the convictions that resulted from what he called a flawed interrogation. That interrogation, in which police hid undisclosed evidence, led to the man's confession. The judge described that confession as "dubious."

The Missouri Attorney General's office elected to appeal the circuit judge's ruling. The AG's office acknowledged that police had failed to disclose evidence. But the AG's office argued that the case had ultimately turned on the suspect's confession.

The Missouri Court of Appeals, however, upheld the circuit judge's ruling. The court issued a 51-page opinion explaining its reasoning.

Barry Scheck, a New York attorney who serves as co-director of the Innocence Project, said he and others who worked on the case were thrilled by the man's release. Scheck said that even with inconclusive DNA evidence, there were several avenues law enforcement could investigate in searching for the person who actually committed the crime.

Source: "Appeals court rejects challenge to St. Louis man's prison release," St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Robert Patrick, 12-27-12

Our firm handles situations similar to those discussed in this post in the St. Louis area. To learn more about our practice, please visit our page on criminal appeals.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
    • Richard H.Sindel | Best Lawyers In America | Best Lawyers - 2016
    • Richard H. Sindel | America's Most Honored Professionals | 2015
    • Top Attorneys in Missouri & Kansas | 2014 | Richard H. Sindel
    • Top Attorneys in Missouri & Kansas | 2013 | Richard H. Sindel
    • Super Lawyers
    • AV Peer Review Rated. Highest Rating For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability
    • Richard H. Sindel | Best Lawyers | Lawyer of the year | 2011 | Criminal Defense: Non-White-Collar St.Louis
    • MATA - Helping To Balance The Scales Of Justice
    • Member of the Missouri Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
    • Member of the National Association of Criminal Defence Lawyers
    • The Bar Association of Metropolitan St. Louis
    • U.S.News| Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms | 2010
    • Charles M. Shaw Award
    • Bar Register Preeminent Lawyers
    • The Missouri Bar
    • Top Listed in Best Lawyers | The world's premier Guide
Email Us For A Response

How Can We Help?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy