Sindel Noble

Providing Legal Help When You Need It Most

Malicious prosecution alleged in sex offense case

Prosecutors have great power. This does not only flow from the discretion they have in choosing whether or not to bring certain charges. It also involves the questionable tactics that they sometimes use before or during trial, such as withholding evidence from the defense. Sometimes such tactics cross the line and become prosecutorial misconduct.

In a recent case in New York, a 26-year-old man whose sex crime charges were dismissed has sued the district attorney's office. The suit not only alleges malicious prosecution, but also malicious prosecution and false imprisonment. The dynamics of the case shed light on how serious the issues are with charges of sex offenses in St. Louis or elsewhere in Missouri.

In the New York case, a man was jailed at Rikers Island for ten months without bail. The sex offense charges against him were finally dismissed when difficult questions arose regarding the credibility of the accuser and how prosecutors handled potentially exculpatory evidence.

The case had begun with much fanfare. It included charges against three other co-defendants on allegations of rape, assault and sex trafficking charges.

But it began to come apart when a police report became available indicating a key witness, an alleged rape victim, changed her story.

An assistant district attorney resigned when she refused to yield to pressure to keep prosecuting the case despite the alleged victim's partially recanted story.

A case like this provides an unsettling window into the lengths that prosecutors sometimes go to in trying to get convictions. It can happen anywhere in the country, given our adversarial system. That's one reason why defense lawyers are so important - to protect against prosecutorial overreaching.

Source: "Ex-Defendant Sues Prosecutors After Rape Charge Is Dropped," New York Times, Alan Feuer, 10-9-12

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
    • Richard H.Sindel | Best Lawyers In America | Best Lawyers - 2016
    • Richard H. Sindel | America's Most Honored Professionals | 2015
    • Top Attorneys in Missouri & Kansas | 2014 | Richard H. Sindel
    • Top Attorneys in Missouri & Kansas | 2013 | Richard H. Sindel
    • Super Lawyers
    • AV Peer Review Rated. Highest Rating For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability
    • Richard H. Sindel | Best Lawyers | Lawyer of the year | 2011 | Criminal Defense: Non-White-Collar St.Louis
    • MATA - Helping To Balance The Scales Of Justice
    • Member of the Missouri Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
    • Member of the National Association of Criminal Defence Lawyers
    • The Bar Association of Metropolitan St. Louis
    • U.S.News| Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms | 2010
    • Charles M. Shaw Award
    • Bar Register Preeminent Lawyers
    • The Missouri Bar
    • Top Listed in Best Lawyers | The world's premier Guide
Email Us For A Response

How Can We Help?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy